You are currently viewing Emmerdale: John Sugden and Ella Forster related, a new fan theory predicts

Emmerdale: John Sugden and Ella Forster related, a new fan theory predicts

Composite image of John and Ella on Emmerdale (Credit: ITV/Composite: ED!)
Who is John Sugden really?

Viewers of Emmerdale have speculated that John Sugden and Ella Forster may be linked, implying that the enigmatic newcomer is not who he seems to be.

Victoria’s estranged brother John recently moved to the village. After remaining, he caused a stir with his new neighbours and developed a turbulent romance with Aaron Dingle.

John recently moved to the area. (Source: YouTube)

Is John, nevertheless, everything he seems? Some fans are questioning if Aiden is indeed a Sugden after seeing a set of dog tags with the name “Aiden” written on them. Additionally, a fan hypothesis suggests that since Ella has just recently moved back to the hamlet, they could be related.

Ella recently returned to the village (Credit: ITV)

Emmerdale fan theory suggests John and Ella could be related

Many followers posted their thoughts about John’s “true” identity in a Reddit thread. And while they exchanged ideas, one thought that upended the current quo came to light.

“Are we convinced that John is unquestionably a Sugden? One admirer said, “I thought he took something with a different name out of his pocket.”

Another hypothesis is that since Ella and John have been living in their cars, they may be connected or something. They make every effort to keep their relationship a secret so that no one is aware of it. Another person made the suggestion, “They might work together to assist each other join the Sugden dynasty, etc.

Newcomer ‘John’ quickly caught Aaron’s eye (Credit: ITV)

“I believe that John is the one who actually stole John’s identity and whose name was on the dog tags.” A third person stated, “That’s why he’s so ready to leave town and not become connected to Victoria or Harry.

Some, though, were less convinced.

“There’s been much too much anticipation for a new Sugden to simply play a different role. One fourth person said, “I’m sure he’ll be who he says he is; the dog tags were just meant to raise suspicions.”


What is John Sugden hiding, and who precisely is he?

Leave a Reply